By Sarjo Barrow, Esq.
Grief shows up in different ways. While mourning my father, I came across reports on the Hajj fraud case and have kept coming back to them.
Imagine saving for years for the journey of a lifetime, only to learn it may never happen. Now imagine your mother or father dying before they could make Hajj. I cannot know how those families carry that loss. Losing a parent hurts, however well that parent lived.
Their loss is personal. The state’s response is public, and that is my concern.
What was charged?
According to reports, the accused faces one count of obtaining money by false pretenses, since amended to about D36 million, under section 265 of the Criminal Offences Act, 2025:
“A person who by any false pretence, and with intent to defraud, obtains from another person anything capable of being stolen … commits a misdemeanour, and is liable on conviction to imprisonment for three years.”
Three years is the maximum, whether the amount is D1,000 or D36 million. The accused has pleaded not guilty. For simplicity, I assume all alleged payments postdate the 2025 Act.
Who is overseeing the prosecution?
Police prosecutors are handling the case. I have long argued that prosecutions in today’s Gambia belong with the Ministry of Justice’s public prosecutors, not the police; until then, serious cases need the Ministry’s oversight.
The Attorney General may appoint qualified counsel as a Public Prosecutor (Criminal Procedure Act, 2025, section 75(1)). The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), with the Attorney General’s approval, may “take over and continue any criminal proceeding that has been instituted by any other person or authority” (Constitution, section 85(1)(b)). A case this size deserves that oversight.
A problem with the wording
False pretenses is a fair charge in principle. But section 264 defines a false pretense as a representation “of a matter of fact, either past or present.”
A promise about the future is not, by itself, a statement of existing fact. Nor does a failed journey alone prove fraud. The position is different if the accused falsely represented that visas were secured, Hajj slots were available, or travel had been confirmed.
News reports describe the money as obtained “after promising to facilitate their travel to Mecca.” I have not seen the charge sheet, which is not public, so I cannot say whether that wording is the charge’s or a reporter’s. But if it reflects the charge, it raises a concern, because section 264 speaks of existing facts, not future promises. In fairness, trial reporting also describes a witness who said he was told the company still had Hajj slots. If the court credits testimony like that, it could show the kind of representation the law requires. That is for the court to decide.
Why only one count?
Each pilgrim deceived into paying is “another person” under section 265, and so a separate offense, even if they paid through a middleman. Section 141 of the Criminal Procedure Act lets such offenses be tried together, each as its own count.
A “gross amount” count covering many victims is allowed only for theft offenses (section 142(11)), not false pretenses. False pretenses may well be warranted on the evidence, but one count grouping every victim sits uneasily with the text of the law. Whether that reflects inexperience or oversight, it is what professional supervision exists to catch.
A stronger charge
As charged, a conviction carries at most three years, and a first-time offender could receive far less: a fine instead of imprisonment, a suspended sentence, or probation (Criminal Offences Act, section 34(3); Criminal Procedure Act, sections 268 and 280).
Yet the same Act offers a potentially stronger alternative: theft by an agent. Money given with a direction to apply it to a specified purpose stays the payer’s property “until the direction has been complied with” (section 221). Stealing property “entrusted … to apply, pay or deliver for any purpose” carries up to ten years (section 235(b)), and using such money at will is fraudulent even with intent to repay (section 218(2)(e)).
The difference is striking. Using the gross-amount rule, a single theft count could cover all the victims and carry ten years. Charged victim by victim, consecutive sentences could reach 20 years before a first-class magistrate, or 14 and 10 before second- and third-class courts (sections 5 and 6(5)). A suspended sentence would be barred (section 268(3)), and a magistrate could still try the case (section 5(1)). Theft by an agent also sidesteps the wording problem: it turns on how entrusted money was used, not on proving a false statement of existing fact.
Not every failed package is theft, and what happened to the money matters. Still, the gap is hard to overlook: three years against ten or even twenty, for the same alleged conduct. Why was the stronger charge not brought, or at least considered alongside the existing one? The public deserves an answer.
The deeper problem is the law itself. The 2025 Act compounded it by carrying over, almost word for word, the false-pretenses provision of a criminal code dating to 1933, flat three-year cap and all. Many jurisdictions now grade theft by amount to reflect its severity; in the United States, Wisconsin, for one, makes theft over $100,000 a felony carrying up to 12½ years. The 2025 Act needs reform.
Fidelity to everyone
The accused is presumed innocent, and public anger does not diminish his right to a fair trial. But justice must also mean something to pilgrims who saved for years and never made the journey.
The DPP, as the public prosecutor, owes the public an explanation, without prejudicing the trial, of whether the charge was reviewed. The National Assembly owes one too: why does fraud carry a three-year maximum regardless of the amount?
A prosecution should not be judged by how loudly the public demands punishment, nor by how quietly the charge sheet is prepared. The law must do its work. Where it falls short, those who make it must do theirs.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not represent those of his employer or the government.




