By Sainabou Sambou
Defense counsel F.C. Anyanwu has told the High Court that the prosecution has failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Ass Malick Njie raped a 12-year-old boy near the QCell building in the Kanifing Municipality in February 2022.
The case, before Justice Ebrima Jaiteh, involves a charge under Section 3(1)(a) of the Sexual Offenses Act, 2013, punishable under Section 4(1)(a)(iii)(bb) of the same Act. Prosecutors allege that on or about 5 February 2022, Njie intentionally had sexual intercourse with the complainant through the anus under coercive circumstances.
In his final address, Anyanwu stressed that the accused remains presumed innocent and that the burden of proof rests solely on the prosecution throughout the trial. He argued that the State’s case rests largely on the complainant’s testimony and circumstantial evidence, without the independent corroboration required under Section 180(2)(a) of the Evidence Act.
Counsel told the court that corroboration must come from an independent source, implicate the accused, and support the claim that the offense was committed. He noted the absence of eyewitness testimony, forensic evidence linking Njie to the allegation, or any confession.
Anyanwu also questioned the reliability of the medical reports tendered by the prosecution, describing them as inconclusive. He pointed out that a prosecution witness who is a relative of the complainant allegedly examined the boy before he was taken to hospital, raising concerns about the integrity of the subsequent findings. He added that the doctor did not positively link the accused to any injury, and a neutral medical report cannot, by itself, serve as corroborating evidence.
The defense further highlighted what it called material contradictions between the complainant’s testimony and those of other prosecution witnesses concerning the time, place, and sequence of events. Anyanwu argued that the inconsistencies went to the root of the case and that the court could not selectively rely on different parts of the testimonies to strengthen the prosecution’s case.
He also highlighted the failure to produce CCTV footage. A letter from QCell confirmed that footage covering the relevant period had been handed to the police, yet it was never presented despite efforts by both the court and the defense. Counsel said the footage could have assisted the court and questioned the lack of any explanation for its absence.
Concluding, Anyanwu submitted that the prosecution had failed to provide independent corroborative evidence and that the contradictions and questions surrounding the medical reports further weakened its case. He urged the court to resolve any reasonable doubt in favor of the accused and to find that the State had not established guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The prosecution was absent and had not informed the court of its absence. Justice Jaiteh adjourned the matter to 3 December 2026 at 1 pm to allow the State to present its final address in the interest of justice.




